The short answer
The last sale is the newest deed with a real, arm's-length price. It is often not the newest deed. Transfers into a trust, between relatives, out of an estate or between an owner and their own LLC record a $0 or nominal amount, and a deed that sells several lots for one price does not tell you what any single lot sold for. Skip those and use the newest priced sale, but keep the newer transfer for who owns it now.
Step by step
- List the deeds on the lot in recorded date order.
- Mark each as priced or unpriced. Unpriced means $0, a nominal amount, a family or trust transfer, or a multi-lot package with no per-lot price.
- The newest priced deed is the last sale. Its date and price go in your comps.
- The newest deed of any kind gives the current owner and the owner-since date.
- Write a note when they differ, such as "transferred in 2024, no price recorded (trust)".
Where the data goes wrong
What we have run into building property reports from these records:
- Using the newest deed as the last sale prices a long-held house at $10, which breaks a CMA and any equity estimate built on it.
- An earlier rule we used stopped the sale history at an unpriced package deed. Owners asked for the last real priced sale instead, so we now look past it.
- NJ has the same problem and its own answer: the state codes non-usable deeds. A sale with a non-usable code should not be a comp.
Common questions
Should I use a family sale as a comp?
No. A sale between relatives is not arm's length and does not show market value.
Where can I see recent NYC sale prices?
DOF publishes rolling sales and annual sales files by borough.