1. Match the property type and model first
A comparative market analysis (CMA) is only as good as its comps. The Fannie Mae Selling Guide, which sets standards for appraisals on loans Fannie Mae buys, says comparables should share physical and legal characteristics with the subject, such as site, room count, finished area, style, and condition. They do not need to be identical.
Start with the filter that matters most: the same kind of property. A two-family house is not a comp for a one-family house, and a condo unit is not a comp for a co-op unit. On a block of attached row houses, a sale of the same model on the same block usually tells you more than a larger set of mixed sales.
2. Start tight on distance, then widen
Fannie Mae directs appraisers to use sales from the same market area, subdivision, or project when possible, and to explain any decision to expand the area. It also says not to expand boundaries just to include competing neighborhoods. A practical sequence:
- Search the same block or building.
- Widen to a short radius inside the same neighborhood.
- Widen again only if you still have fewer than three usable closed sales.
- Write down why you widened, the same way an appraiser must.
Watch for boundaries that change value within short distances, such as a school zone line, a highway, a flood zone, or a change in zoning. Fannie Mae notes that flood zone should be considered.
3. Use recent closed sales
Fannie Mae requires at least three closed comparables in the sales comparison approach and says sales that closed within the last 12 months should be used. Older sales are acceptable with a time adjustment or an explanation, such as few recent sales. In a fast-moving market, sales from the last few months carry more weight than sales from a year ago.
In New York City, the Department of Finance publishes rolling sales files covering tax class 1, 2, and 4 properties sold in the last 12 months, by borough, with neighborhood, building type, square footage, and other fields. They are a useful starting list of closed sales.
4. Bracket size, bedrooms, and bathrooms
Choose comps that bracket the subject: at least one somewhat larger and one somewhat smaller, with similar bedroom and bathroom counts. Bracketing lets you see whether the subject sits between known prices instead of extrapolating from sales that are all bigger or all smaller.
Compare finished living area on the same basis for every sale. If one source reports gross building area and another reports interior living area, the price per square foot will not be comparable.
5. Compare condition and renovations
Condition is one of the characteristics Fannie Mae lists for similarity. Two houses of the same model can sell far apart if one has a new kitchen, baths, and systems and the other needs everything. Use listing photos, descriptions, and permit history to judge condition, and group comps as renovated, average, or needs work relative to the subject.
Fannie Mae allows foreclosures and short sales as comps when they are the best available, but says the appraiser must address condition differences and stigma and must not assume they equal the subject.
6. Verify the recorded sale price
An MLS sold price can be entered wrong, and some sales never appear in the MLS. For Manhattan, the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens, ACRIS covers recorded property documents from 1966 to the present, so you can open the recorded deed and check the parties, the recorded date, and the consideration. For Staten Island and New Jersey, check the county's own land records.
If the MLS price and the recorded price disagree, read the deed image before choosing one. A deed for a different lot or unit can look like a match.
7. Exclude transfers that are not market sales
The NYC Department of Finance glossary for its sales files says a $0 sale indicates a transfer of ownership without cash consideration, and gives transfers from parents to children as one reason. Nominal amounts such as $10, and transfers between related parties or into a trust or LLC owned by the same person, should be treated the same way: they do not show what a buyer paid on the open market.
- Remove $0 and nominal-price deeds.
- Remove sales where the grantor and grantee share a surname or address, unless you confirm it was an open-market sale.
- Flag bulk sales of several lots on one deed, since the price covers more than one property.
8. Adjust, and use listings as context only
For each comp, adjust its price for the differences that remain: size, bedrooms and bathrooms, condition, lot, parking, and time since sale. Adjust the comp toward the subject, not the other way around, and keep each adjustment consistent across comps.
Fannie Mae says contract offerings and current listings can be used only as supporting data, not to meet the minimum of three closed sales. Pending and active listings show where the market is heading and what buyers can choose from today. Use them to explain your range, not to set it.
9. Important limitations
A CMA is a broker's or agent's opinion of market value, not an appraisal. Fannie Mae standards are written for appraisers on loans it buys and are cited here as a well-documented reference, not as a rule for CMAs. Public sales data can lag, can contain errors, and may not reflect concessions or the condition at the time of sale. Verify every comp you rely on and explain your choices to the client.